By Mark DaCosta- In a world grappling with multifaceted crises, the question of leadership at the United Nations has taken centre stage. As Guyana pushes for its Permanent Representative to the United Nations (UN), Carolyn Rodrigues-Birkett’s election as Secretary-General, significant concerns arise regarding her ability to represent not just the interests of a political party but the collective aspirations of all citizens.
The main argument presented by Lincoln Lewis, General Secretary of the Guyana Trades Union Congress, emphasises the critical need for a representative who transcends party lines. He asserts that the qualities necessary for the Secretary-General extend beyond political allegiance; they require a commitment to justice, fairness, and the values enshrined in the United Nations Charter. As the world moves towards establishing a rules-based international order, it remains vital that the representatives we choose embody these principles and are respected globally for their impartiality.
Lewis expresses doubts about Rodrigues-Birkett’s suitability for this diplomatic role, indicating that her public record often reflects a hyper-partisan stance rather than the independent voice expected from someone aiming to lead the UN. He warns that such a perception undermines our nation’s aspirations and its legacy of non-alignment, which once earned us international respect. “A nation whose diplomatic tradition was built upon non-alignment and peaceful coexistence should be encouraging negotiations — not appearing to take sides in conflicts that threaten global stability,” he argues.
In a rapidly changing geopolitical landscape, relationships between historically dominant nations are evolving, and nations of the Global South are increasingly vocal in their demands for a fairer international system. In this context, it becomes crucial that the next Secretary-General possesses the moral authority to challenge established powers, whether they are in Washington, Moscow, Beijing, Tel Aviv, or Tehran. The analyst underlines that, during the Cold War, our country successfully navigated global ideological divides through principled diplomacy. “Our voice carried weight because it was respected as independent. That legacy is now at risk,” he warns.
Lewis critically examines recent actions taken by Rodrigues-Birkett and the government she represents, particularly during heightened tensions in the Middle East. Many observers noted that our country’s stance appeared one-sided, failing to uphold the principles of restraint and dialogue that are vital for international peace. “Guyana adopted positions that many viewed as aligning with one side of an increasingly polarised conflict,” he points out, suggesting that our historical commitment to impartiality is being jeopardised.
An alarming trend is emerging, whereby Rodrigues-Birkett’s role has been muddied by her overt support for the governing People’s Progressive Party/Civic (PPP/C) during election seasons, raising serious questions about her capacity to act as an unbiased representative of our nation at the UN. “That is not the conduct expected of an international public servant aspiring to become the world’s chief civil servant,” remarks the General Secretary.
Furthermore, unresolved human rights issues domestic to our country compound the concerns over her candidacy. Lewis highlights that numerous African Guyanese organisations have had to petition international bodies over allegations of discrimination and unequal treatment. “Rather than engaging these concerns through meaningful dialogue, the PPP Government has too often dismissed them,” he states. The PPP’s unwillingness to address issues raised by these community groups raises questions about the government’s commitment to the very democratic ideals Rodrigues-Birkett would be expected to defend on the global stage.
The General Secretary also draws attention to the significant absence of our nation’s representation at the recent conference in Ghana on reparations for slavery — a critical issue that should resonate deeply with the struggles faced by many citizens of African descent. He emphasises that the PPP’s lack of engagement reflects a broader pattern of marginalising organisations perceived as independent, leading to a political culture where dissent is met with exclusion. As he notes, “A discernible pattern has emerged in which African Guyanese organisations, African leaders, and institutions perceived to be independent of the PPP/C are marginalised rather than engaged.”
Lewis insists that the issues arising from a political culture characterised by exclusion and vindictiveness drastically contrast with our founding principles. By failing to prioritise inclusiveness, we are straying from the ideals that our Constitution champions, notably the call for participatory democracy. “Guyana’s Constitution speaks to inclusive democracy. Article 13 calls for the inclusion of citizens and their organisations in the management and decision-making processes of the State,” he emphasises.
As our nation contemplates the future of its representation on the international stage, the candidature of Carolyn Rodrigues-Birkett for Secretary-General must be critically assessed. The argument presented by Lincoln Lewis serves as a stern reminder that true leadership in the UN requires a commitment to the greater good above partisan interests. Our national representation must reflect the dignity and rights of all citizens, transcending political loyalty to foster a united, equitable future.
