Sunday, November 22, 2026
Village Voice News
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Letters
  • Global
  • Columns
    • Eye On Guyana
    • Hindsight
    • Lincoln Lewis Speaks
    • Future Notes
    • Blackout
    • From The Desk of Roysdale Forde SC
    • Diplomatic Speak
    • Mark’s Take
    • In the village
    • Mind Your Business
    • Bad & Bold
    • The Voice of Labour
    • The Herbal Section
    • Politics 101 with Dr. David Hinds
    • Talking Dollars & Making Sense
    • Book Review 
  • Education & Technology
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Letters
  • Global
  • Columns
    • Eye On Guyana
    • Hindsight
    • Lincoln Lewis Speaks
    • Future Notes
    • Blackout
    • From The Desk of Roysdale Forde SC
    • Diplomatic Speak
    • Mark’s Take
    • In the village
    • Mind Your Business
    • Bad & Bold
    • The Voice of Labour
    • The Herbal Section
    • Politics 101 with Dr. David Hinds
    • Talking Dollars & Making Sense
    • Book Review 
  • Education & Technology
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Village Voice News
No Result
View All Result
Home Op-ed

Government Seeks to Scrub Criticism Instead of Addressing Its Causes

Admin by Admin
November 22, 2026
in Op-ed
L-R President Irfaan Ali and Attorney Selwyn Pieters

L-R President Irfaan Ali and Attorney Selwyn Pieters

0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Aubrey Subner- There is something profoundly disquieting about the spectacle of a government engaging a lawyer to interface with social media companies in an effort to have online content deemed objectionable to the administration removed. The implications extend far beyond questions of defamation or the responsibilities of social media platforms. They strike at the very foundations of democratic governance, freedom of expression, political accountability and the responsible use of public resources.

President Dr Mohamed Irfaan Ali has confirmed that his administration retained Canada-based Guyanese attorney-at-law Selwyn Pieters to address social media content that the Government considers misleading, defamatory or objectionable.

READ ALSO

Border Bartering, Where’s Guyana’s Chief –Pt III

Border Bartering -Does Guyana Have A Say -Pt II

At his November 13, 2026 press conference, the President defended the engagement, stating:

“I don’t see any difficulty in hiring a lawyer who I believe is competent, just like our AG is exceedingly competent, maybe one of the finest. But I believe that this guy has [a] specific skill set that is necessary to combat the misinformation, the disinformation, the lies that people are peddling on social media.”

He went further: “So you want me to sit back and allow people to assassinate the character of myself, senior officials.”

Explaining why he had delegated the responsibility, he added: “The President does not have the time every day to write to Facebook. I don’t even examine what happens. But I have the trust of someone to examine those things and to take the appropriate steps.”

These statements are revealing. They raise a fundamental question: Is the Government protecting the public against demonstrably false and defamatory information, or is it deploying public resources and institutional influence to shield those in political office from scrutiny, criticism and embarrassment?

There is a profound difference between these objectives, and a democratic government must never allow that distinction to become blurred.

The fundamental problem is that the Government is not a private citizen.

A government cannot approach criticism in the same way as a private individual. Public officials voluntarily occupy positions of power and, with that responsibility, accept a heightened obligation to withstand public scrutiny. Their decisions, conduct, policies and performance are legitimate subjects of public debate, including criticism that may be uncomfortable, harsh or politically damaging.

This does not mean that public officials surrender their legal rights or must tolerate defamatory falsehoods. They are entitled to seek redress where demonstrably false statements cause reputational harm. But the existence of that right does not automatically justify the creation of a government-backed mechanism to monitor, challenge or seek the removal of online commentary.

The critical issue is not whether misinformation exists. It unquestionably does. Nor is it whether defamation should have consequences. It should. The issue is who determines what constitutes misinformation, what standards are applied, and whether the machinery of government is being used to distinguish genuine falsehoods from legitimate dissent.

A government cannot be the ultimate arbiter of its own credibility.

One of the greatest dangers in contemporary political discourse is the tendency of governments to characterise uncomfortable criticism as misinformation, disinformation or malicious falsehood.

These terms have specific meanings. They should not become convenient labels for dismissing opposing opinions, investigative reporting, political commentary or public dissatisfaction.

A social media post does not become false simply because the President or a senior government official considers it unfair. Nor does criticism become defamatory merely because it damages the reputation of someone in authority.

In a functioning democracy, citizens must be free to question government decisions, challenge official explanations, expose perceived wrongdoing and express dissatisfaction without fearing that their criticism will trigger an organised campaign to have their voices removed from public platforms.

The remedy for inaccurate information should ordinarily be evidence, transparency, explanation and, where necessary, lawful recourse through established legal channels. It should not be the casual invocation of government influence to make inconvenient speech disappear.

The President’s explanation also raises an important question of public accountability: Who is paying for this engagement, what precisely is the lawyer authorised to do, and under what safeguards is the work being conducted?

If public funds are being used, taxpayers are entitled to know the scope, cost and public purpose of the arrangement. They should also be assured that the engagement is not being used to protect individual political reputations or suppress legitimate criticism.

The statement that the President does not have time to examine social media content himself makes the need for transparency even more compelling. Delegating the responsibility does not eliminate presidential accountability. Indeed, it makes clear guidelines, independent oversight and safeguards against abuse all the more necessary.

Ultimately, governments must understand that criticism is not the enemy of democracy. It is one of its essential instruments.

When citizens complain about governance, the appropriate response is not necessarily to challenge the platforms carrying their complaints. It is to examine why those complaints are being made in the first place.

If citizens are dissatisfied with public services, explain the shortcomings and demonstrate what is being done to correct them. If allegations of wrongdoing emerge, investigate them transparently. If official statements are misrepresented, publish the evidence and set the record straight.

A government confident in its performance should have little reason to fear scrutiny. Its strongest defence against misinformation is credibility, transparency and a demonstrable commitment to truth.

There is a dangerous irony in attempting to combat misinformation by creating the perception that government is more interested in controlling the conversation than addressing the issues driving it.

No government can legislate itself into public confidence, nor can it outsource its way out of public dissatisfaction.

The internet may provide a platform for falsehoods, but it also provides citizens with an indispensable space to question power. That space must not be compromised by an administration that mistakes criticism for hostility and accountability for character assassination.

The test of democratic leadership is not how effectively a government can silence its critics. It is how confidently it can answer them.

A government should be judged not by how successfully it removes criticism, but by how honestly and effectively it addresses the reasons that criticism exists.

ShareTweetSendShareSend

Related Posts

L-R President Irfaan Ali, GHK Lall
Op-ed

Border Bartering, Where’s Guyana’s Chief –Pt III

by Admin
November 22, 2026

By GHK Lall- Where is the president?  Guyana’s Pres Ali, not the MV Barima Commission president.  Pres Ali was out...

Read moreDetails
GHK Lall
Op-ed

Border Bartering -Does Guyana Have A Say -Pt II

by Admin
November 21, 2026

By GHK Lall- Look where oil rich Guyana is.  Examine what others feel ordained to do with it.  Like a...

Read moreDetails
Egland Gomes
Op-ed

Fellow Guyanese, When Do We Say “Enough Is Enough?”

by Admin
November 20, 2026

By Egland Gomes- Fellow Guyanese at home and in the diaspora, our homeland is dangerously close to authoritarianism and dictatorship....

Read moreDetails
Next Post
STEM GUYANA PHOTO

STEMGuyana, K12YouthCode Partner to Launch Virtual STEM Club for Children Across Guyana


EDITOR'S PICK

‘Commuters to feel the heat’  

August 9, 2021

Long Waits, Confusion and Delays Mar $100,000 Grant Programme

May 30, 2026
Jason Holder got the big wicket of Shreyas Iyer on his way to a four-wicket haul•Associated Press

Test-match skills hold Holder in good stead at the IPL

May 4, 2026
President Irfaan Ali

CARICOM Heads meet today in Jamaica to deal with the Haitian Crisis

March 11, 2024

© 2024 Village Voice

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Letters
  • Global
  • Columns
    • Eye On Guyana
    • Hindsight
    • Lincoln Lewis Speaks
    • Future Notes
    • Blackout
    • From The Desk of Roysdale Forde SC
    • Diplomatic Speak
    • Mark’s Take
    • In the village
    • Mind Your Business
    • Bad & Bold
    • The Voice of Labour
    • The Herbal Section
    • Politics 101 with Dr. David Hinds
    • Talking Dollars & Making Sense
    • Book Review 
  • Education & Technology
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us

© 2024 Village Voice