Friday, May 16, 2025
Village Voice News
[adning id="37476"]
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Letters
  • Global
  • Columns
    • Eye On Guyana
    • Hindsight
    • Lincoln Lewis Speaks
    • Future Notes
    • Blackout
    • From The Desk of Roysdale Forde SC
    • Diplomatic Speak
    • Mark’s Take
    • In the village
    • Mind Your Business
    • Bad & Bold
    • The Voice of Labour
    • The Herbal Section
    • Politics 101 with Dr. David Hinds
    • Talking Dollars & Making Sense
    • Book Review 
  • Education & Technology
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Letters
  • Global
  • Columns
    • Eye On Guyana
    • Hindsight
    • Lincoln Lewis Speaks
    • Future Notes
    • Blackout
    • From The Desk of Roysdale Forde SC
    • Diplomatic Speak
    • Mark’s Take
    • In the village
    • Mind Your Business
    • Bad & Bold
    • The Voice of Labour
    • The Herbal Section
    • Politics 101 with Dr. David Hinds
    • Talking Dollars & Making Sense
    • Book Review 
  • Education & Technology
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Village Voice News
No Result
View All Result
Home Letters

OUR COURTS SHOULD REVIEW TWO OF ITS KEY PRACTICES. 

Staff Reporter by Staff Reporter
August 9, 2020
in Letters
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Dear Editor

Since the NCM in 2018, the courts have impacted on our political destiny as never before. This impact, with an election petition looming, could soon become even more game-changing.

READ ALSO

Amna Ally will be missed — not just as a leader, but mentor, fighter and symbol of strength

Open letter to President Ali- “You must act now”

In the rulings of the recent election cases, several court practices raised my concerns. I here highlight two of them, which may have implications for the quality of our jurisprudence going forward. The first concerns the trustful reliance by our lawyers and judges on prior case laws (precedents) that likely were decided in judiciaries polluted by local politics. Many of these precedents were birthed in countries ranging from weak democracies to full totalitarian; or were birthed in societies now described as democratic but during a period of undemocratic governance.

In such countries or during such times, judiciaries would have been assaulted by direct political pressure, political meddling or full political control. Regardless, every prior court decision from every corner of the Commonwealth seems to have the power to shape or bind opinions in our courts. That these prior cases have not apparently been vetted for their moral and legal legitimacy is troubling and undermines the quality of our jurisprudence.

No doubt, assessing the political context behind court decisions from Africa to Asia to the Caribbean is an enormous challenge. It is a challenge normally taken up by legal academics and law departments. Whether these are up to the task or not, our courts must be more vigilant in their use of prior cases from countries whose politics and political history have influenced the outcome of cases as much as, or even more than, good law.

Secondly, I see no wisdom in the practice where our Court of Appeal (CoA) does not issue a single majority decision, but instead allows each judge to offer individual opinions. This practice, if indeed it is, undercuts the quality of rulings as these do not benefit from the expertise and experience of all CoA judges working together. For clarity and consistency, courts must speak with one voice, whether singly or as a synchronized majority. Where differences of opinion exist within a panel of judges, our CoA would do well to present its rulings to the public in the highly structured manner used by the US Supreme Court.

Yours faithfully,
Sherwood Lowe

ShareTweetSendShareSend

Related Posts

Letters

Amna Ally will be missed — not just as a leader, but mentor, fighter and symbol of strength

by Admin
May 16, 2025

Dear Editor, A few days ago, we bid farewell to a stalwart of Guyanese politics, Comrade Amna Ally — a...

Read moreDetails
Letters

Open letter to President Ali- “You must act now”

by Admin
May 15, 2025

Dear Editor, This is an open letter to our Head of State, President Irfaan Ali. For sometime now, law abiding...

Read moreDetails
Letters

GuySuCo Made Over US$200M More in Revenue from 2016 – 2020 than from 2021-2025

by Admin
May 15, 2025

Dear Editor,   On May 8, 2025, the Stabroek News published an article titled ‘GuySuCo serves up another dismal  performance in...

Read moreDetails
Next Post

Janet Jagan time in office and resignation  


EDITOR'S PICK

The demonstrations have been growing since the coup

Myanmar army suspends laws limiting forces, hunts protest backers 

February 14, 2021
CARICOM Secretary-General Ambassador Irwin LaRocque (left) and newly elected Prime Minister of Belize, John Briceño. (CARICOM)

CARICOM SG congratulates new Belizean Prime Minister

November 17, 2020
NCERD Director, Ms Quenita Walrond-Lewis

69 educators graduate from MoE’s Education Management Certificate Course

July 6, 2022

Government distributes eyeglasses to Region One residents

March 26, 2023

© 2024 Village Voice

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Letters
  • Global
  • Columns
    • Eye On Guyana
    • Hindsight
    • Lincoln Lewis Speaks
    • Future Notes
    • Blackout
    • From The Desk of Roysdale Forde SC
    • Diplomatic Speak
    • Mark’s Take
    • In the village
    • Mind Your Business
    • Bad & Bold
    • The Voice of Labour
    • The Herbal Section
    • Politics 101 with Dr. David Hinds
    • Talking Dollars & Making Sense
    • Book Review 
  • Education & Technology
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us

© 2024 Village Voice