A retired senior diplomat has issued a stinging rebuke of President Irfaan Ali’s handling of the deepening Venezuela-Guyana border crisis, calling his leadership “careless,” “divisive,” and “dangerously dependent on foreign muscle.” In an exclusive interview with Village Voice News, the veteran envoy condemned Ali’s foreign policy posture as hollow grandstanding and accused him of undermining national unity while outsourcing Guyana’s sovereignty to the United States.
“He ran to America for help—by default. He’s banking on foreigners to defend our land while our people remain divided, anxious, and voiceless in their own country,” the diplomat said. The critique cut deep, accusing Ali of cowardice cloaked in diplomacy. Rather than galvanising the nation across racial and political lines to stand up for Guyana’s territorial integrity, Ali has, according to the diplomat, “made us a scourge in our own land.”
Weak Leadership in the Face of Real Threats
The remarks come as tensions with Venezuela escalate to their most dangerous point in decades. On March 1, 2025, a Venezuelan naval vessel entered Guyana’s maritime space and approached an oil production vessel in the Stabroek Block. This incursion was followed by Venezuela’s defiant move in May to hold illegal elections in the disputed Essequibo region, in violation of an International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruling. While the international community—including the U.S., OAS, and CARICOM—stood with Guyana, the retired diplomat questioned what would happen if those allies shift focus or walk away.
“The only thing keeping Venezuela from crossing that border with tanks and troops is Big Brother to the north. But what happens when they stop caring?”
The diplomat also blasted what they described as Ali’s lack of foresight, vision, and statesmanship, asserting that under his leadership, the country has become more divided and insecure.
“He’s a buffoon. All blow. Full of gear but no idea. He threatens his own people more than he threatens the aggressors. He governs with coercion and spectacle, not strategy.”
“Diplomatic” Posturing or Abdication of Responsibility?
The former diplomat, who has represented Guyana at multiple regional and international levels, argued that Ali’s actions have lacked both diplomatic sophistication and national authenticity. The President’s responses, they said, are performative—a mixture of fiery speeches, shallow media rounds, and flashy international appeals—while he ignores the core responsibility of building a united front at home.
“In all the years before Ali, we maintained functional, even productive, relations with Venezuela—yes, even during the People’s National Congress (PNC) years. We had trade, cultural exchanges, and backchannel diplomacy. Today, we have headlines and helplessness.”
They pointed to earlier administrations that pursued quiet diplomacy and strategic deterrence, rather than “the dependency syndrome and performative victimhood” that now defines Guyana’s foreign policy posture.
Jagdeo’s Legacy and the Erosion of Sovereignty
The diplomat did not spare Vice President Bharrat Jagdeo either. They linked the deteriorating border situation to then President Bharrat Jagdeo’s previous approach, accusing him of enabling Venezuela’s claims through passive appeasement. “Jagdeo tried to mollify the Venezuelans, even allegedly offering channel to the sea. That’s not diplomacy—it’s surrender by installments.”
They claimed both Jagdeo and Ali share responsibility for weakening Guyana’s strategic standing and creating a leadership vacuum in the face of a rising geopolitical threat.
China, the U.S., and the Fragile Balancing Act
Adding to the geopolitical unease, China has recently expressed support for Venezuela against any external threats to its “sovereignty,” further complicating the region’s security calculus. Guyana now finds itself in a precarious position—sandwiched between an aggressive neighbor and a wary superpower protector, all while its own internal cohesion is unraveling.
“You can’t defend a nation divided. You can’t expect foreign soldiers to fight for a people too afraid to raise their own voices,” the diplomat warned.
The Emperor Has No Clothes
The Village Voice interview is not merely a critique of policy—it’s an indictment of character. President Irfaan Ali is portrayed not as a wartime leader rising to meet a historic threat, but as a figurehead buoyed by press conferences, diplomatic platitudes, and foreign backing.
“Ali has made the Essequibo controversy about America, about oil, about legality—but never about us. He has failed to make this a people’s cause. And when the smoke clears, that failure will cost us more than land—it will cost us our soul as a nation.”
As Venezuelan threats mount and global alliances shift, Guyana faces not just a border crisis—but a crisis of leadership.
Background
Venezuela has long claimed sovereignty over the Essequibo region, a resource-rich area west of the Essequibo River comprising around two-thirds of Guyana’s land mass. This claim is rooted in historical assertions of Spanish colonial boundaries. Although an international tribunal awarded the territory to Guyana through the 1899 Paris Arbitral Award, Venezuela rejected this outcome in 1962 and signed the 1966 Geneva Agreement, which failed to resolve the controversy. Tensions escalated following the discovery of offshore oil in 2015, prompting renewed Venezuelan assertions, including a controversial referendum in 2023 and efforts to conduct elections in the Essequibo—moves that attracted widespread condemnation an attack on Guyana’s sovereignty and by the International Court of Justice for violating its order not to alter the status quo.
