Editorial: NGSA Results Falsified? Manickchand Owes the Nation the Truth

The Minister of Education, Priya Manickchand, would have us believe that Guyana has experienced a miraculous turnaround in education overnight. According to her (SN June 26), the National Grade Six Assessment (NGSA) pass rate has surged from 49% to 63% in just one year. Even more astonishing, she claims that 55.51% of students passed Mathematics, a subject that has long been the Achilles’ heel of our education system.

This announcement should not inspire celebration, it should trigger suspicion, scrutiny, and serious concern.

A 14-point national gain in standardized scores is unprecedented, even in countries that spend billions annually to reform education. According to the U.S. National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), often called “the nation’s report card,” no U.S. state has seen a 14-point gain in a single year in mathematics or language arts, despite decades of reforms, advanced analytics, and massive budgets. Gains of 2–3 percentage points per year are considered excellent.

So how did Guyana, without any disclosed systemic reforms, without any new curriculum overhauls, without proven interventions at scale, suddenly catapult student scores in a way that defies regional and global precedent?  This smells of manipulation, not merit.

Minister Manickchand must now be compelled to release the raw data;

•The score distribution by student and by region

•A breakdown of school-level results

•Information about who graded the exams, and under what protocols

•Copies of the actual 2025 exam papers compared to prior years

•Public documentation of intervention programs that explain this leap

If she cannot provide these, then the results must be considered illegitimate and politically motivated.

This is not the first time Manickchand has turned education reporting into a public relations circus. After more than two decades in government, literacy rates remain shockingly low across the country. According to the Ministry’s own data presented in 2021, nearly 60% of students were reading below grade level by Grade 3. International benchmarks such as the World Bank’s “Learning Poverty” indicator placed Guyana at alarming levels.

So what changed in 12 months? Nothing, except the approach to spin, not substance.

There are only a few explanations for this statistical anomaly;

1.The exam was drastically simplified, making it easier to pass.

2.The grading was altered, either via relaxed marking schemes or inflated scores.

3.The final data was massaged, as part of a wider effort to construct a political narrative ahead of the 2025 elections.

This is a classic tactic of embattled ministers; manufacture a win when the real outcomes are indefensible.

Our Children Deserve Better. This case is not about numbers, it’s about children, it’s about contempt for education, it’s about students who are disadvantaged, it’s about truth, trust, and transparency in a nation where our future depends on a well-educated generation.

The public must demand an independent audit of the NGSA results. The Guyana Teachers’ Union, opposition MPs, parent associations, and civil society must not sit silently while statistical sleight-of-hand is used to whitewash decades of failure.

Education reform is hard. It takes years of focused investment, curriculum revision, teacher support, and family engagement. One does not stumble into success, you build it with intention and integrity.

If Manickchand truly cares about children and not just her political survival, she should welcome scrutiny. Until then, we must treat her claims for what they appear to be, deliberate deception masquerading as progress.