Friday, February 3, 2023
Village Voice News
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Letters
  • Global
  • Columns
    • Eye On Guyana
    • Hindsight
    • Lincoln Lewis Speaks
    • Future Notes
    • Blackout
    • From The Desk of Roysdale Forde SC
    • Diplomatic Speak
    • Mark’s Take
    • In the village
    • Mind Your Business
    • Bad & Bold
    • The Voice of Labour
    • The Herbal Section
    • Politics 101 with Dr. David Hinds
    • Talking Dollars & Making Sense
    • Book Review 
  • Education & Technology
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Letters
  • Global
  • Columns
    • Eye On Guyana
    • Hindsight
    • Lincoln Lewis Speaks
    • Future Notes
    • Blackout
    • From The Desk of Roysdale Forde SC
    • Diplomatic Speak
    • Mark’s Take
    • In the village
    • Mind Your Business
    • Bad & Bold
    • The Voice of Labour
    • The Herbal Section
    • Politics 101 with Dr. David Hinds
    • Talking Dollars & Making Sense
    • Book Review 
  • Education & Technology
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Village Voice News
No Result
View All Result
Home Op-ed

OpEd: The Presumption of Innocence and the Principle of Natural Justice

Staff Writer by Staff Writer
August 19, 2022
in Op-ed
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Support Village Voice News With a Donation of Your Choice.

By Paul Slowe CCH, DSM, Assistant Commissioner (Ret’d)

Following the murder of Quindon Bacchus by a member of the Guyana Police Force on June 10, 2022, the public was informed that the Police Complaints Authority would be investigating the incident. I pointed out then that the Police Complaints Authority Act, Chapter 17:02 provides for the Police Complaints Authority to “supervise”, and not by itself investigate an incident of that nature.

READ ALSO

Black History Month must be used as a catalyst for a better Guyana- Green

The Oil & Gas Sector: Implications For Agriculture Being More Than Food On The Table

The Police Complaints Authority subsequently submitted a report to the Director of Public Prosecutions with recommendations for three members of the Guyana Police Force to be charge with the following criminal offence:

  1. Lance Corporal Kristoff DeNobrega, murder contrary to common law.
  2. Lance Corporal Thurston Simon:-

(a)   Conspiracy to commit a felony, to wit, murder contrary to section 102 (a) of the Criminal Law Offences Act, Chapter 8:01; and

Advertisement

(b)  Conspiracy to obstruct the course of justice contrary to section 320 of the Criminal Law Offences Act Chapter 8:01.

  1. Sergeant Dameion McClennon :-

(a)   Perverting the course of justice contrary to section 329 of the Criminal Law Offences Act Chapter 8:01; and

(b)  Unlawful possession of two rounds of ammunition contrary to section 16 (2) (a) of the Firearm Act Chapter16:05 as amended by the Firearm and Ammunition Act No 17 of 2007.

It must be noted that the Director of Public Prosecutions did not advice the police to institute some of the charges recommended by the Police Complaints Authority.

Additionally, the Director of Public Prosecutions recommended that Lance Corporal Simon should be charged with a disciplinary breach.

Having had the opportunity to examine the report prepared by the Police Complaints Authority I must say that I am disappointed with the sparseness of the recommendations.

My disappointment stems from the fact that the report clearly identified several other ranks who committed criminal offences and disciplinary breaches, yet no recommendation was made for them to be charged with the identified offences and breaches.

The three ranks who were charged appeared in court on July 5, 2022 and were all refused bail and remanded to prison.

The standard procedure in cases where ranks of the Guyana Police Force are charged with a criminal offence is for them to be interdicted from duty with effect from the date they appeared in court, pending the outcome of the criminal charge.

There are currently several ranks of the Force who are interdicted pending the outcome of various criminal charges, including a gazetted officer who was committed to stand trial in the High Court for allegedly engaging in sexual activity with a 13-year-old child and a sergeant who was recently charged with larceny by public officer; just to give two examples.

I was therefore shocked to learn that shortly after the appearance in court of the three ranks charged in the Quindon Bacchus case they were all summarily dismissed from the Guyana Police Force with effect from July 5, 2022, the same day they first appeared in court to answer the charges.

I was taught the legal principle of the “presumption of innocence”:

The principle says that “every person accused of any crime is considered innocent until proven guilty. Under the presumption of innocence, the legal burden of proof is thus on the prosecution, which must present compelling evidence to the trier of the facts”.

I was also taught the principle of Natural Justice, which says that: “natural justice is a technical terminology for the rule against bias and the right to a fair hearing. While the term natural justice is often retained as a general concept, it has largely been replaced and extended by the general duty to act fairly”.

Section 34 (1) of the Police Act, Chapter 16:01, states “the commissioner may at any time discharge any subordinate officer or constable from the force on the grounds that, having regards to the conditions of the force, the usefulness of the subordinate officer or constable thereto and any other relevant circumstance, such discharge is desirable in the public interest”.

In the past the administration of the Guyana Police Force and the Police Service Commission made use of section 34 (1) to summarily dismiss ranks.

This practice was challenged on numerous occasions and the courts have repeatedly held that section 34 (1) cannot be used to dismiss ranks without applying the principle of natural justice. In other words, the ranks must be given an opportunity to be heard.

I recall that when I was the Chairman of the Police Service Commission I had a conversation with the Solicitor General in relation to the same subject. I was informed that the Attorney General’s Chamber was at its wits end to deal with cases where ranks of the Guyana Police Force were dismissed without the principle of natural justice being applied and had moved to the court to seek redress. I was further informed that in all of those cases the Attorney General’s Chamber had to concede and pay out large sums as damages to the affected ranks.

It is to be noted that the dismissal of Lance Corporal Simon also flies in the face of the recommendation from the Director of Public Prosecution that he should be charged with a disciplinary breach.

It is evident that the dismissal of the three ranks violated the sacrosanct principles of the presumption of innocence and natural justice, and is therefore unlawful.

I am reminded that some persons in society speak eloquently about the rule of law. I would like to take this opportunity to state that “the rule of law is a principle under which all persons, institutions, and entities are accountable to laws that are: Publicly promulgated. Equally enforced. Independently adjudicated. And consistent with international human rights principles”.

The dismissal notices referenced above are unlawful and should be immediately withdrawn; failure to do so must result in swift legal challenge.

We must be reminded that in any country governed by the rule of law citizens should not stand idly by and allow the misguided, misinformed and incompetent to violate the rights of anyone, including persons who are charged with criminal offences.

ReplyForward



Support Village Voice News With a Donation of Your Choice



ShareTweetSendShareSend

Related Posts

Former Prime Minister and Mayor Hamilton Green
Op-ed

Black History Month must be used as a catalyst for a better Guyana- Green

by Admin
February 1, 2023

Fifty years after the African slaves secured their release from bondage in the United States of America, a descendant of...

Read more
Dr.  Arlington Chesney
Op-ed

The Oil & Gas Sector: Implications For Agriculture Being More Than Food On The Table

by Admin
January 31, 2023

An integrated and holistically conceptualised oil and gas (petroleum) sector could assist in developing a transformed and modernised Guyana and...

Read more
GHK Lall
Op-ed

Parliamentary budget debate  

by Staff Writer
January 29, 2023

By GHK Lall The budget debate was over before it began.  Yes, it was that much of a foregone conclusion, with...

Read more
Next Post

Caribbean people to make a call for urgent climate action

EDITOR'S PICK

Baramita housewife collapses, dies on journey to shop

November 16, 2020
Demonstrators break TV equipment outside the the U.S. Capitol on Wednesday, Jan. 6, 2021, in Washington. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana)

Lawmakers vow to investigate police after Capitol breach

January 7, 2021

Cops seize guns, ammo during Corentyne raid

August 25, 2020

President Ali must shift from political rhetoric and offer government action where it is most needed

December 11, 2020

© 2022 Village Voice | Developed by Ink Creative Agency

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Letters
  • Global
  • Columns
    • Eye On Guyana
    • Hindsight
    • Lincoln Lewis Speaks
    • Future Notes
    • Blackout
    • From The Desk of Roysdale Forde SC
    • Diplomatic Speak
    • Mark’s Take
    • In the village
    • Mind Your Business
    • Bad & Bold
    • The Voice of Labour
    • The Herbal Section
    • Politics 101 with Dr. David Hinds
    • Talking Dollars & Making Sense
    • Book Review 
  • Education & Technology
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us

© 2022 Village Voice | Developed by Ink Creative Agency