Ghosts of 2016 writ large as England, West Indies meet again

In a tournament that has so far been characterised by plucky challenges from unfancied underdogs, here’s a clash of big beasts to whet the appetite. Okay, so West Indies may not be among the big hitters on a global scale any more – hell, they didn’t even qualify for the ICC’s last two 50-over tournaments. But in a 20-over gunfight, they’ve proven time and again that their particular brand of physical might is right. Not least against Wednesday’s familiar foes at the Wankhede.

A clash of England and West Indies in a T20 World Cup is an inevitable opportunity to revisit one of the greatest finales of all time. Ten years ago in Kolkata, not quite to the month, Carlos Brathwaite launched Ben Stokes into the stratosphere time and time again to swipe the 2016 trophy from England’s grasp, almost as the engraver was getting to work.

But if the raw aggression of that moment left England feeling robbed, they could not say that they hadn’t been warned. For it was at the Wankhede, in their very first match of that same campaign, that they came a cropper in the face of an even more ferocious beating, as the mighty Chris Gayle blitzed 11 massive sixes in his 47-ball hundred.

Fittingly, those were the only two defeats of England’s knowingly naïve campaign. Perhaps they came too early in their ongoing white-ball awakening for the players to possess the street-smarts required to bring down an IPL-trained mean machine. But the lessons they learned would be invaluable, especially when the 2019 World Cup reached its own clutch moments.

England still have two survivors from that campaign – Adil Rashid and Jos Buttler, whose recognition of the value of six-hitting was his single biggest takeaway from that tournament; that, for a player who trusts his ability to clear the ropes, even the steepest of chases can be broken down into a handful of big hits when the match-up is right.

But, as Sam Curran noted after his nerveless death over had saved the day against Nepal, the lessons of that tournament cut both ways as they continue to echo down the generations. “I weirdly thought of the 2016 final, when Carlos got hold of Stokesy,” he told the BBC afterwards. “I was thinking, ‘Well, if I execute, he’s not going to hit me for six.'”

As for West Indies, Johnson Charles and Jason Holder remain from that squad of ten years ago, alongside their head coach, Daren Sammy – whose captaincy proved instrumental in drawing his players together to fight for a common cause. As he demonstrated on match eve, shooting the breeze with the media in a 15-minute address that touched every issue imaginable in West Indies cricket, his class of 2026 are unlikely to lack for motivation against these opponents.

History and precedent aside, this is a significant match-up for more basic qualification reasons. On the face of it, the jeopardy in Group C has been reduced by Bangladesh’s decision to withdraw, but Nepal are clearly itching for an upset and, as Scotland showed with a comprehensive win over the likely stragglers Italy, they have embraced their unlikely opportunity with gusto.

It’s an occasion that deserves to be savoured. As the weeks of uncertainty over India versus Pakistan ended up demonstrating, there’s still something precious about proper historical rivalries on the grandest stages that the game can offer. England and West Indies have each won two T20 World Cup titles, tying them with India as the most successful teams in the tournament’s history. Their storied pasts will inform the present on Wednesday night, as each team seeks to stride on into the future.

England: WWWWW (last five completed T20Is, most recent first)
West Indies: WWWWW

One of the main reasons for England’s angst in that Nepal run-chase was the unexpectedly brutal treatment meted out on Adil Rashid. Not only did he go wicketless for the first time in 25 T20I innings, dating back to the last World Cup, he was launched at a rate of 14 runs an over, the second-most expensive T20I spell of three or more overs in his career. Nepal’s ability to pick his variations was the clincher, borne no doubt of their own familiarity with the art of legspin, and given his form coming into the tournament, there’s no question of Harry Brook losing any faith in Rashid’s impact. As the man himself said on this site last week, “you have to have a big heart as a spinner”. It’s about to be tested once more.

Quality spin remains an Achilles heel for England’s heavy hitters, and in Gudakesh Motie, they’ll be reunited with a left-arm spinner who knows how to cramp their style. Ten of his 40 T20I wickets have come in his frequent clashes with England, including a matchwinning haul of 3 for 24 in Tarouba two years ago. He was recently left out of their tour of New Zealand after a dip in form linked to a technical flaw, but last month he reasserted his trump-card status with a matchwinning haul in a rain-reduced game against South Africa.

Once again, England were quick out of the blocks with their starting XI. Just the one change from that fraught opener against Nepal, with Luke Wood’s left-arm seam making way from the heavier deck-hitting capabilities of Jamie Overton. He hits a long ball too, which might be useful down the order, given West Indies’ own six-hitting reputation.

England: 1 Phil Salt, 2 Jos Buttler (wk), 3 Jacob Bethell, 4 Tom Banton, 5 Harry Brook (capt), 6 Sam Curran, 7 Will Jacks, 8 Liam Dawson, 9 Jamie Overton, 10 Jofra Archer, 11 Adil Rashid.

West Indies know their XI, but have chosen not to divulge it just yet. There was not much reason to change a winning formula from their tournament opener against Scotland.

West Indies (probable): 1 Brandon King, 2 Shai Hope (capt & wk), 3 Shimron Hetmyer, 4 Rovman Powell, 5 Sherfane Rutherford, 6 Romario Shepherd, 7 Matthew Forde, 8 Jason Holder, 9 Akeal Hosain, 10 Shamar Joseph, 11 Gudakesh Motie.

So far, the Wankhede has not been the free-flowing run-carpet that it can sometimes be. England’s ambitions were stymied by Nepal’s spinners, while India encountered trouble up top against some sticky seam bowling from USA, on what has at times been a two-paced surface. Sammy, however, expects plenty of runs this time out. The 7pm start means that dew is likely to be a factor, so the team that wins the toss will probably bowl first.

ESPNCricinfo