This column congratulates United States of America House Representatives member, Hakeem Jeffries on being elected Speaker of that House, for we are now assured that there is someone in that important position who has more that some scant awareness of what is taking place in Guyana. A few years ago, the People’s Progressive Party (PPP) sought to chide Mr. Jeffries for what they considered negative comments he made about the political situation in Guyana.
On that occasion, I indicated that each member of the US Congress has a chief of staff and other staff and connections from which to acquire information about any subject they wish to address. Therefore, it is ‘most unlikely that Congressman Hakeem Jeffries and his colleagues would have commented negatively on what has been taking place in Guyana since the PPP/C took government in 2020 without having first adequately informing themselves’(‘The PPP’s dilemma,’ VV: 22/08/2021).
Today, I will consider two very important issues: firstly chairman of the International Decade of People of African Descent Assembly – Guyana (IDPADA-G) Mr. Vincent Alexander’s recent concern that PPP lobbyists, who are paid by the state, are almost daily in the US capital advancing that party/government’s account of developments in Guyana while opposition and civil society groups face major financial constraints in presenting what actually is taking place.
And secondly, since the general secretary of the PPP made his governance proposal to the PNCR, I am on record as supporting his extremely vague position, and the Opposition should take the opportunity to understand precisely what he has in mind before deciding the way forward. Indeed, from what reaches me from various PNCR/APNU spokespersons, I am not certain how they view the political future of Guyana. One must only hope that there is now a consensus that neither the PPP nor PNCR can singly extricate Guyana from the socio/political mess it is in.
Make no mistake, IDPADA-G is very important to African Guyanese regardless of their political orientation. This is particularly so since we are operating in an autocratic environment with a largely ethnic-orientated government that has almost total control of all state institutions. In my last article I called on the regime to demonstrate that those who have been accusing it of widespread discrimination against Africans are wrong by conducting ‘an independent ethnic disparity analysis’ and, as requested by IDPADA, to establish and maintain a comprehensive system of disaggregated ethnic data. (VV: “Guyana is ‘Israel lite” 08/11/2026).
This is very much in keeping with the position taken by IDPAD-G and a request for help in this direction made directly to the previous US Democratic Administration has had a somewhat favourable response. If it is proven that discrimination has taken place and has negatively affected African development, adequate compensation should be assessed and paid by the State.
Apart from the help that can be given by the various diaspora individuals and organisations, the present digital information environment is quite permissive. Indeed, it would be difficult for the relevant US congressional representatives not to have a reasonably good idea of what is taking place in Guyana since it has been on the problematical side of the US government agenda since the early 1950s.
Very early on, there was Jimmy Carter and (still is) the Carter Centre that became arguably the most appropriately located friend and development strategist for Guyana. This played to Cheddi Jagan’s advantage because his government was not rooted in the kind of ethnic/political dominance that led to Carter leaving Guyana in 2004 disappointed. There has been much water under the bridge having to do with the Opposition, but by its very nature, the Centre is an institution from which objective information on Guyana can be garnered.
On the second issue, look around the world and you will see that Guyana’s ethnic political context is not unusual and the obstinance associated with the political elites managing this kind of a context is legendary. In my view, this attitude usually results from an inadequate grasp of the nature and power of social structures that is usually clouded by the seductive relationship of ethnic alliance and political power. As a result, after some 3,600 people had lost their lives and two years of negotiations, even the vaunted Northern Ireland ‘Good Friday Agreement’ of 1998, almost came to naught until Billy Wright, a leader of the unionist group who was still strongly objecting to the peace process, was assassinated in prison by the IRA and violence escalated.
Since the PPP’s general secretary’s public recognition of the need for some rapprochement there has been much talk in PNCR circles about the need for the kind of coalition with which the late Robert Corbin was associated, without recognising that although such coalitions were successful in wining elections/government they did not and could not lead to the required national ethnic/reconciliation: quite the opposite.
‘Men make their own history, but they do not make it as they please; they do not make it under self‑selected circumstances, but under circumstances existing already, given and transmitted from the past. The tradition of all dead generations weighs like a nightmare on the brains of the living’ (Karl Marx (1852) ‘The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte’).
Marx was here pointing to the nature of social structures: the social framework that both enables and constrains individual actions. It exerts power by organizing who holds authority, control over resources, and influence over norms. To be actionable one’s policies must be properly located and shaped to fit the historical conditions and material circumstances that precede us. Thus, it is not just a matter of what you want, it is also what the social structure allows you to do or indicates how you may be able to achieve your goals by other means.
Where democracy is concerned, ‘Free institutions are next to impossible in a country made up of different nationalities. Among a people without fellow feeling … the united public opinion necessary to the working of a representative government cannot exist.’ (John Stuart Mills, ‘Of nationality as connected with Representative Government, 1861).
At the very of beginning of Guyana’s bid for independence in 1954, the British government established the Robertson British Guiana Constitutional Commission, which was pessimistic about Guyana’s democratic future. ‘We do not altogether share the confidence that a comprehensive loyalty to British Guiana can be stimulated among peoples of such diverse origins.’ Perhaps it is for this reason that they offered Cheddi shared governance, but having already committed Guyana to Soviet Communism, he refused while Forbes Burnham accepted.
In his speech marking the 20th anniversary of the Good Friday Agreement, President Bill Clinton defined it as ‘a work of genius that’s applicable if you care at all about preserving democracy.’ He briefly but adequately outlined the major political elements that need to be constitutionalised in some detail if the structural obstacles in the way of democratic formation in countries such as Guyana are to be overcome.
There needs to be the normal elements: majority rule; minority rights; individual rights; the rule of law; the end of violence; shared political decision-making and shared economic benefits. But the ‘most interesting thing was that by creating a space for the identity and the interests and the values of all the people involved in a framework which protected democracy and let future demographic, economic and political changes take Northern Ireland wherever it would go – it was a work of surpassing genius’ (‘The Good Friday Agreement and Guyana).
What is required, then, is not merely coalition governments of various kinds stuck within a majoritarian framework but the constitutionalising of ethnic and other minority rights and various other checks and balances to a point where, for example, contrary to the workings in the normal democratic process, ethnic minorities in opposing parties can decide to coalesce on specific issues that fundamentally affect the interest of their race/ethnicity.
‘[T]o the extent that the constitutional arrangements ignore this structural deficiency, tension, alienation, disturbances, and underdevelopment result. There is little point in blaming the community leaders as in the competitive political environment, their stories do win them maximum support. There is little point in pleading right-doing for with similar facts the opposite story can also be told. Nowhere has this story played out differently. It is a mistake to blame the outcome on anyone. Power sharing becomes inevitable because of the logic of political cleavage in competitive democracies.’ (Scott Orr ‘The Theory and Practice of Ethnic Politics: How What We Know about Ethnic Identity Can Make Democratic Theory Better (2007))’
There is also some concern that the PPP’s general secretary did not include We Invest in Nationhood (WIN) in his offer, but WIN cannot help with the level of ethnic estrangement existing today. Furthermore, political parties are expected to make a good showing in three to four elections to be taken seriously. The Alliance for Change also began by taking votes from a sick PNC in 2006 but look at where it is today. First time in the ring one cannot expect to beat a sick contestant and be seriously taken as a champion.
The PNCR remains the most democratic political party in Guyana, and indeed and this is also the cause of its present convulsions. When democracy fails to throw up the personalities one wants one must simply grit one’s teeth, wish the incumbent well and if necessary, wait for another day. Indeed, after what happened before, during and after the 2020 elections, Aubrey Norton and Terrence Campbell, being relatively new to the upper echelons of the previous government are not inappropriate leaders.




