Monday, November 16, 2026
Village Voice News
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Letters
  • Global
  • Columns
    • Eye On Guyana
    • Hindsight
    • Lincoln Lewis Speaks
    • Future Notes
    • Blackout
    • From The Desk of Roysdale Forde SC
    • Diplomatic Speak
    • Mark’s Take
    • In the village
    • Mind Your Business
    • Bad & Bold
    • The Voice of Labour
    • The Herbal Section
    • Politics 101 with Dr. David Hinds
    • Talking Dollars & Making Sense
    • Book Review 
  • Education & Technology
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Letters
  • Global
  • Columns
    • Eye On Guyana
    • Hindsight
    • Lincoln Lewis Speaks
    • Future Notes
    • Blackout
    • From The Desk of Roysdale Forde SC
    • Diplomatic Speak
    • Mark’s Take
    • In the village
    • Mind Your Business
    • Bad & Bold
    • The Voice of Labour
    • The Herbal Section
    • Politics 101 with Dr. David Hinds
    • Talking Dollars & Making Sense
    • Book Review 
  • Education & Technology
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Village Voice News
No Result
View All Result
Home Regional

JAMAICA | Who Gave the Order? Lady Lawla Owner and Crew Sue Jamaica Over Trawler Torched by US Coast Guard

Admin by Admin
November 16, 2026
in Regional
An AI illistration of the Lady Lawla on fire allegedly set by the US Coast Guard with alleged permission of the Jamaican Government.

An AI illistration of the Lady Lawla on fire allegedly set by the US Coast Guard with alleged permission of the Jamaican Government.

0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Six years after the US Coast Guard torched a Jamaican trawler on the high seas, allegedly with Kingston’s permission, its owner and crew want more than US$3.8 million and a declaration that their own Government acted unlawfully.

MONTEGO BAY, Jamaica, Calvin G. Brown,  — The owner and crew of the Lady Lawla, the Jamaican fishing trawler set ablaze and sunk by the United States Coast Guard in October 2020, have gone to the Supreme Court seeking damages from both the Government of Jamaica and the United States of America, along with a declaration that Jamaican officials broke Jamaican law when they gave the Americans the go-ahead.

READ ALSO

BVI and UNDP deepening development cooperation for resilience Government of the British Virgin Islands

Caribbean Airlines Confirms Data Security Incident At Third-Party Reservations Provider

The claim, numbered SU2026CV04197, was stamped by the Civil Division on October 9, 2026, three days short of the sixth anniversary of the boarding. A second stamp records its receipt at the office of the Director of State Proceedings on October 22. The Attorney General of Jamaica is named as first defendant, sued under the Crown Proceedings Act for the acts of the Jamaica Defence Force (JDF), its Coast Guard and the Minister of Foreign Affairs. The United States is the second defendant.

The claimants are Kingston businessman David Harry Chin, registered owner of the steel trawler, and four crewmen: captain Anthony Newton Clarke, engineer Warren Rowe, and fishermen Radcliffe Mark Simmonds and Howard Patterson. They are represented by attorney-at-law Bert Samuels of Knight, Junor and Samuels.

What follows is drawn from their Particulars of Claim. These are allegations. They have not been tested in court, and no defence from either government was among the documents seen by WiredJa.

Eighty miles out

According to the claim, the Lady Lawla left Kingston with a Jamaican government clearance dated October 5, 2020, bound for Punto Fijo, Venezuela. At about 6:30 a.m. on October 12, some 80 miles from Kingston on the high seas, two US Coast Guard vessels approached. Fifteen minutes later, the document says, armed officers boarded with guns drawn.

The search ran until about 3:00 p.m. and took in the fuel tanks, water tank, engine room, fish box and twelve 15-gallon gasoline containers on deck. “Nothing illegal was found on the Vessel,” the claim states. A second team returned with testing kits, after which the Coast Guard asserted that the gasoline containers held liquid cocaine. Captain Clarke, the crew say, told the officers the containers held gasoline mixed with two-stroke oil.

On the second day, the men say, they were ordered off their vessel at gunpoint, made to strip naked in front of armed officers, handed thin paper suits and chained by the feet to the deck of a US vessel.

“Danger to navigation”

The heart of the case against Kingston lies in what happened next. On or about October 14, the claim alleges, the JDF or other agents of the Government granted permission to the US Coast Guard cutter Diligence, and the trawler was destroyed on the stated basis that it was a “danger to navigation”. The GPS, autopilot, radios, a flat-screen television and fuel were removed first, the claimants say. Nobody told the crew. They learned of it when they saw smoke, and watched their boat burn and sink.

To prove that Jamaica authorised the destruction, the claimants say they will rely on the sworn affidavit of a US Drug Enforcement Administration special agent, filed on October 30, 2020 in the US District Court for the Southern District of Florida.

The crew learned their boat was being destroyed when they saw the smoke.

The pleading argues that the JDF had no power to give such permission. Under the Maritime Drug Trafficking (Suppression) Act, which gives domestic effect to the 1997 Shiprider Agreement, a treaty state that finds evidence of trafficking must ask Jamaica’s Central Authority for directions on what becomes of the vessel. Here, the claimants say, there was no court order and no confirmed drugs. They further plead that Jamaica authorised the boarding without first satisfying itself that reasonable grounds existed, and failed to withdraw that permission once the first search turned up nothing.

Eighty days

Between October 18 and November 1, the crew say, they were shuttled between about four Coast Guard vessels, chained for long periods, exposed to sun and rain, poorly fed and refused medical attention. On one vessel, they allege, they were held beside toilet and shower facilities whose waste water ran across the space in which they were kept. Clarke suffered an asthma attack.

On or about October 27, the claim says, Jamaica waived its jurisdiction without consulting the men, the owner or their lawyers, clearing the way for a US prosecution. A federal complaint alleging conspiracy to possess a controlled substance with intent to distribute followed on October 30. Landed at St Petersburg, Florida, on November 1, the men were taken to the Hernando County Detention Center, where they say they could reach neither family nor a lawyer of their choosing for 14 days.

On December 15, 2020, US Magistrate Judge Chris M. McAliley dismissed the complaint after scientific tests found no illicit drugs in the substance taken from the trawler. The men were not released until December 30 and reached Jamaica on New Year’s Eve. Their Jamaican passports, the claim says, have not been returned in the six years since.

The pleaded injuries are personal. Rowe’s mother died while he was detained, and he says he learned of it only on his return. Patterson says his waist shrank from 36 inches to 24. All four report continuing nightmares.

The Government’s own words

The claimants lean heavily on the public record. Their pleading cites the January 15, 2021 statement to the Senate by Foreign Affairs Minister Senator Kamina Johnson Smith. In it, they say, she acknowledged that deficiencies identified after the 2017 interception of another Jamaican vessel, the Jossette, had not all been remedied before the Lady Lawla was stopped, accepted that the matter had not been handled in keeping with the applicable conditions, and confirmed that Washington had apologised at a bilateral meeting on January 6, 2021. Press reports at the time recorded the Minister telling the Senate of that apology.

They also cite remarks attributed to the then US Ambassador, Donald Tapia, in the Jamaica Observer of December 31, 2020, to the effect that provision existed for the owner to seek compensation for the vessel. The complaint against Kingston is that, despite letters to the Ministry, it never pressed that case with Washington on its citizens’ behalf.

The bill

Special damages are put at US$3,841,480 plus J$6,927,300, and continuing. The largest items are Chin’s: US$1.3 million for the replacement value of the trawler and US$2.07 million in lost income, calculated at US$30,000 a month. On top of that the claimants seek damages for false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, negligence, trespass to goods and assault, together with constitutional, aggravated and exemplary damages, and two declarations that Jamaican officials acted unlawfully in authorising first the search and then the destruction.

What the court must weigh

The claim faces obvious hurdles. Whether a Jamaican court can exercise jurisdiction over the United States, a foreign sovereign, is likely to be an early question. The Crown, for its part, will have the opportunity to argue that its authorisations were a lawful exercise of treaty obligations made on the information available at the time.

Yet the questions the claim raises reach beyond one trawler. The Shiprider Agreement lets a foreign power board Jamaican-flagged vessels with Jamaica’s consent. Four fishermen and a boat owner now want a Jamaican judge to say what that consent demands of the State that gives it, and what the State owes its own citizens when the partner gets it wrong.

ShareTweetSendShareSend

Related Posts

L-R: BVI Special Envoy Mr. Benito Wheatley, UNDP Resident Representative Mr. Nick Booth, and UNDP  Deputy Regional Director LAC Ms. Bettina Woll
Regional

BVI and UNDP deepening development cooperation for resilience Government of the British Virgin Islands

by Admin
November 16, 2026

The British Virgin Islands (BVI) and United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) have committed  to deepening development cooperation as the BVI...

Read moreDetails
Regional

Caribbean Airlines Confirms Data Security Incident At Third-Party Reservations Provider

by Admin
November 16, 2026

Caribbean Airlines has been informed by Amadeus IT Group, S.A., its reservations service provider, that an unauthorised party exploited a...

Read moreDetails
News

Caribbean Airlines Announces Flight Schedule Updates for November 15

by Admin
November 15, 2026

Caribbean Airlines on Saturday announced schedule adjustments affecting some of its services for Saturday, November 14, and Sunday, November 15,...

Read moreDetails

EDITOR'S PICK

World Bank Provides US$26M to Strengthen Flood Risk Management in Guyana 

November 20, 2020

Forum on China-ASEAN cultural exchange, cooperation held in south China

December 9, 2024
Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) Director, Dr Carissa Etienne

PAHO urges Caribbean people to take Covid vaccines

August 12, 2021
Regional Nursing Body Chair Nester Edwards (right) Outlines CARICOM nursing strategy

Nursing the Future: CARICOM’s Bold Vision for Healthcare Excellence

August 18, 2025

© 2024 Village Voice

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Letters
  • Global
  • Columns
    • Eye On Guyana
    • Hindsight
    • Lincoln Lewis Speaks
    • Future Notes
    • Blackout
    • From The Desk of Roysdale Forde SC
    • Diplomatic Speak
    • Mark’s Take
    • In the village
    • Mind Your Business
    • Bad & Bold
    • The Voice of Labour
    • The Herbal Section
    • Politics 101 with Dr. David Hinds
    • Talking Dollars & Making Sense
    • Book Review 
  • Education & Technology
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us

© 2024 Village Voice